In my view replacing incandescent bulbs with CFLs is not a perfect energy efficiency measure as that could further degrade the environmental quality substantially and as that could further jeopardize public health severely especially in India because of weak environmental norms and because of next to nothing enforcement of the environmental norms.
According to a report published by the Central Pollution Control Board, Government of India, in India the used CFL lamps are thrown in the garbage bins and finally into the municipal garbage dump-sites, contaminating air, water and soil. Most of the used lamps are broken either at transit solid waste bins
(provided by local civic authority) or broken during the transport to the final disposal site. A portion of the mercury, in vapor form, is released into the air; whereas rest of the mercury is released onto the soil with further possibility of getting into the surface and / or ground water bodies through the leachate from soil.
Typical Mercury concentration in CFLs varies considerably depending on the
manufacturer, the manufacturing year, the manufacturing country.
Mercury content
(mg/lamp) Country/Region
5 EU
10 Canada
12-30 Russia
Mercury is very toxic and linked with a wide range of health effects including irreversible damage to the human nervous system.
Inhalation:
Mercury vapor is highly toxic via inhalation. It can cause severe respiratory tract damage. Symptoms of mercury toxicity include sore throat, coughing, pain, tightness in chest, breathing difficulties, shortness of breath, headache, muscle weakness, anorexia, and gastrointestinal disturbance, ringing in the ear, liver changes, fever, bronchitis and pneumonitis. Mercury can be absorbed through inhalation with symptoms similar to those appearing after ingestion.
Ingestion:
Ingestion (through mouth) of mercury may cause burning of the mouth and pharynx, abdominal pain, vomiting, corrosive ulceration, bloody diarrhea.Ingestion may be followed by a rapid and weak pulse, shallow breathing, paleness, exhaustion, tremors and collapse.
Skin Contact:
Contact of mercury with skin causes irritation and burns to skin. Symptoms include redness and pain. It May cause skin allergy and sensitization. Mercury can be absorbed through the skin with symptoms parallel to ingestion.
Eye Contact:
Contact of mercury with eye causes irritation and burns to eyes. Symptoms include redness, pain, blurred vision; may cause serious and permanent eye damage, also depending upon exposure.
Chronic Exposure:
Chronic exposure of mercury through any route can produce central nervous system disorders. It may cause muscle tremors, personality and behavior changes, memory loss, metallic taste, loosening of the teeth, digestive disorders, skin rashes, brain damage and kidney damage. Mercury can cause skin allergies and accumulate in the body. Repeated skin contact with mercury can cause the skin to turn gray in color. Mercury is a suspected reproductive hazard; may damage the developing foetus and decrease fertility in males and
females.
Governments in my view should encourage CFLs usage more and more in the country only if and when the proper recycling facilities are created and closely monitored and only if and when they ensure that the millions of fused/used CFLs do not end up in the garbage bins and landfills and only if and when all the open burnings of trash and garbage are totally and strictly banned during the night and day.
R P Rammohan
Energy Management Consultant
608, Block 18, Raintreepark, KPHB, Hyderabad-500072 India
Phone: +91-40-23851868, 66881868, +91-9440710899
www.linkedin.com/in/rprammohan
rammohanrp@yahoo.com
According to a report published by the Central Pollution Control Board, Government of India, in India the used CFL lamps are thrown in the garbage bins and finally into the municipal garbage dump-sites, contaminating air, water and soil. Most of the used lamps are broken either at transit solid waste bins
(provided by local civic authority) or broken during the transport to the final disposal site. A portion of the mercury, in vapor form, is released into the air; whereas rest of the mercury is released onto the soil with further possibility of getting into the surface and / or ground water bodies through the leachate from soil.
Typical Mercury concentration in CFLs varies considerably depending on the
manufacturer, the manufacturing year, the manufacturing country.
Mercury content
(mg/lamp) Country/Region
5 EU
10 Canada
12-30 Russia
Mercury is very toxic and linked with a wide range of health effects including irreversible damage to the human nervous system.
Inhalation:
Mercury vapor is highly toxic via inhalation. It can cause severe respiratory tract damage. Symptoms of mercury toxicity include sore throat, coughing, pain, tightness in chest, breathing difficulties, shortness of breath, headache, muscle weakness, anorexia, and gastrointestinal disturbance, ringing in the ear, liver changes, fever, bronchitis and pneumonitis. Mercury can be absorbed through inhalation with symptoms similar to those appearing after ingestion.
Ingestion:
Ingestion (through mouth) of mercury may cause burning of the mouth and pharynx, abdominal pain, vomiting, corrosive ulceration, bloody diarrhea.Ingestion may be followed by a rapid and weak pulse, shallow breathing, paleness, exhaustion, tremors and collapse.
Skin Contact:
Contact of mercury with skin causes irritation and burns to skin. Symptoms include redness and pain. It May cause skin allergy and sensitization. Mercury can be absorbed through the skin with symptoms parallel to ingestion.
Eye Contact:
Contact of mercury with eye causes irritation and burns to eyes. Symptoms include redness, pain, blurred vision; may cause serious and permanent eye damage, also depending upon exposure.
Chronic Exposure:
Chronic exposure of mercury through any route can produce central nervous system disorders. It may cause muscle tremors, personality and behavior changes, memory loss, metallic taste, loosening of the teeth, digestive disorders, skin rashes, brain damage and kidney damage. Mercury can cause skin allergies and accumulate in the body. Repeated skin contact with mercury can cause the skin to turn gray in color. Mercury is a suspected reproductive hazard; may damage the developing foetus and decrease fertility in males and
females.
Governments in my view should encourage CFLs usage more and more in the country only if and when the proper recycling facilities are created and closely monitored and only if and when they ensure that the millions of fused/used CFLs do not end up in the garbage bins and landfills and only if and when all the open burnings of trash and garbage are totally and strictly banned during the night and day.
R P Rammohan
Energy Management Consultant
608, Block 18, Raintreepark, KPHB, Hyderabad-500072 India
Phone: +91-40-23851868, 66881868, +91-9440710899
www.linkedin.com/in/rprammohan
rammohanrp@yahoo.com